Spiralists: Why procurement careers rise by going sideways

Dollars And Sense

Paul Rogers analysed the CVs of seven CPOs who spoke at PASA’s recent ConfeX to see if there are any actionable insights. He found senior procurement leaders rarely climb one organisation’s ladder. They spiral up through different industries and employers.

This isn’t research, and I’m not pretending seven CVs prove anything. It is deliberately provocative: a small sample, some striking patterns and a few hypotheses worth arguing about.

I started work on 4 March 1981 as a procurement trainee with a grade of ‘higher clerical officer’. The next level up was scale 1. I was so low in the pyramid that my level did not even have a number. 

At the top, many tiers above me, sat scale 32, and I believed with absolute sincerity that I would work my way from the unnumbered bottom to scale 32 without ever leaving the organisation. 

I got as far as scale nine, then I was overlooked for a promotion and left in frustration. I told people it was a bold career move, but it was actually a tantrum-inspired flounce. 

I have been thinking about that exit because I recently looked at the career histories of seven senior procurement leaders. None of them climbed. They spiralled – and I now think I left too late. 

I recognise that a sample based on seven successful people is biased, with no comparison group of spiralists who moved around and didn’t get ahead. But there are some interesting patterns.

Pattern 1: Sectoral experience

The seven CPOs notched up 53 employers, between four and ten each. Of 40 permanent moves from one employer to another, 33 (83 percent) crossed into a different industry. Each CPO had worked in between two and ten industries, and the median was seven.

This matters because category managers may face decisions about whether to specialise or diversify their category management experience as their careers progress. But if we aspire to leadership positions, we might change the perspective from “which employer?” to “which industry sector?”

Why might sectoral breadth matter to career advancement? 

My reading is that procurement is pattern recognition. Someone who has procured in several industries can tell which supplier behaviour is universal and which is industry-specific. Someone who has only worked in one industry can’t really calibrate what is ‘best practice’, can they?

Pattern 2: The 1-2-3 rule

You’ve probably heard some old lag quote the “three-year rule”. If you haven’t, I’ll be the old lag.

Year one you learn the role, year two you perform in the job and year three you build the springboard for the next job. So, did the CPOs change job about every three years?

The mean was 3.3 years (or 2.5 years after omitting two outliers). The median stint with one employer was 2.2 years. So, perhaps the 1-2-3 rule has some validity? Or should it be the ‘26 month rule’? 

While correlation doesn’t imply causation, one interpretation is that spiralists have one eye on performing in their current role and one eye on their next role. Is it also reasonable to infer that ambition trumps loyalty for spiralists? Probably.

Pattern 3: Transformation takes time

CPOs in senior roles tend to stay in the same role for about 3.5 years. None ended between two and three years. Shorter stints tend to feature earlier in their careers. Once a CPO gets a big job, they either leave within two years or stay for three and a half to four years. Six of the seven CPOs had at least one stint of four years or more. 

My interpretation is that building a function or leading transformation takes longer than three years. If it goes well, CPOs stick around. If it fails, the CPO is asked to leave within 18 months. This aligns with a 2007 CAPS Research study of 30 of the world’s largest companies, which found average CPO tenures of four years or less.

Pattern 4: Functional heritage in procurement matters

I came into procurement as a trainee, and I’m well aware that is not a common route. The received wisdom is that people “fall” into procurement after beginning in a different function, such as law or finance. So, did the CPOs begin their career in a different function?

No. The typical CPO spent less than 10 percent of their career outside procurement. Most started as buyers, category managers or procurement specialists and stayed in procurement. The mean and the median career length are both about 25 years.

However, these CPOs may not represent the broader procurement workforce. A 2025 New Zealand government workforce survey found that 69 percent entered procurement later in their careers. Perhaps many people fall into procurement, but those who reach the top tend to have started there?

Pattern 5: MBAs are more common than procurement qualifications

Only one of the seven CPOs records MCIPS on their CV. In contrast, three hold MBAs. The sample size is small, but the decision to pursue a general business qualification may align with my observation about ambition. The CPOs planned their careers to be leaders, not buyers.

What this means for you

Seven careers is a small sample, but if you want the top job, here’s what I’d take from them:

  • Change industry, not just employer. Most of these CPO moves crossed into a new sector. Next time you move, weigh the industry as heavily as the employer. A sideways step into a new sector may be worth more than a promotion in a familiar one
  • Check your learning at the two-year mark. Around 26 months into a role, ask what you’ve learned this year that you didn’t know last year. If the answer is nothing, switch from ‘passively looking’ to ‘actively looking’
  • Build your springboard before you need it. Have one result you can explain in two minutes at interview, such as a category plan delivered, or a major contract renegotiated. A credible success story beats 36 months of doing the same thing
  • When you land the big job, plan to stay. At head-of-function level, these CPOs either left within two years or stayed for three and a half to four. Show results in the first 18 months, then give the transformation time to pay off
  • Choose qualifications as a future leader, not a buyer. Three of the seven hold an MBA and only one shows MCIPS. A procurement qualification may make you a better procurement professional, but a business qualification may do more for your path to the top
  • Don’t wait to fall in. Most of these CPOs started in procurement and stayed. If you’re early in your career, choosing procurement on purpose is no handicap


I never did get to scale 32, but I did change industry sectors and employers. And I learned that scale nine is a perfectly good place to start looking.

Paul Rogers is Practice Manager at Landell. The opinions expressed in this article are the author’s alone and are not necessarily the opinions of Landell.