KPMG review exposes gaps in Commonwealth supplier integrity safeguards

An independent review of KPMG Australia has recommended stronger powers to bar unethical suppliers from Commonwealth contracts, clearer misconduct-reporting processes and greater senior oversight of procurement.

Commissioned by the Department of Finance (Finance) and released on 22 October, the review by Dr Ian Watt AC found weaknesses in KPMG’s culture, governance and accountability.

It follows March allegations that KPMG audit partners misused confidential client information and that the firm mishandled a whistleblower’s complaint.

Six of the review’s eight recommendations are administrative and are for KPMG, Finance or both to implement. These include KPMG implementing its action plan and Finance monitoring its progress.

However, two recommendations propose broader changes to the Commonwealth Procurement Framework, addressing supplier integrity safeguards and procurement oversight and capability.

The review found that KPMG’s policies, reporting channels and oversight structures did not work effectively in practice. Its handling of whistleblower concerns lacked clear ownership, and the firm failed to connect warning signs and recognise their combined significance.

Watt stressed that the findings were not a judgement on every KPMG employee, noting that virtually all staff had no involvement in the events. He also identified a gap in the government’s powers to act against unethical suppliers.

“The Commonwealth still cannot currently prevent a supplier from bidding for Commonwealth contracts solely because of past unethical behaviour,” the report stated.

Finance can suspend or remove suppliers from panels it manages, while agencies must consider ethical performance when assessing value for money. However, those mechanisms do not provide a general power to exclude suppliers from bidding across the Commonwealth.

The report said existing arrangements rely on suppliers engaging constructively and implementing satisfactory remediation. If they are unwilling to address serious ethical issues, the government may have limited options without creating significant legal risk.

The review also found limited guidance on where to report concerns, which could result in disclosures reaching the wrong entity or going unaddressed. It warned that gaps in cross-government coordination create a risk that unethical suppliers will continue to win contracts.

Watt also emphasised that conduct beyond Commonwealth contracts can reveal weaknesses in a supplier’s governance, confidentiality and accountability.

The review recommends strengthening the Supplier Code of Conduct framework, including sanctions that could restrict or prohibit suppliers from bidding. 

It also proposes clearer guidance on notification obligations, better reporting pathways, greater support for agencies assessing disclosures and improved information sharing, while calling for a consistent approach to existing procurements and contracts when establishing agreements that suppliers will not bid for Commonwealth work.

Another recommendation calls for agency heads and other senior officials to strengthen procurement oversight, alongside improvements in procurement capability across government.

Finance has accepted the administrative recommendations, including the proposed approach to existing procurements and contracts. 

The government said it will consider the proposed sanctions, reporting and information-sharing changes and recommendations on senior oversight and procurement capability.

KPMG’s chief executive and chair accepted the findings and recommendations, with the firm agreeing to extend its pause on bidding for new Commonwealth work until 28 February 2027. 

The arrangement covers new engagements, including panel engagements and new third-party contracts appointing KPMG as a subcontractor.

KPMG will also provide Finance with an implementation plan by 15 November 2026 and its first quarterly progress report by 29 January 2027.

Finance will monitor progress for three years, or until all actions and recommendations have been implemented. It may also reinstate bidding restrictions later if warranted.