The feasibility and origins of AUKUS, Australia’s biggest defence procurement program worth $368 billion, have been called into question, with former Labor ministers, academic experts and former defence officials demanding an investigation.
This comes as the procurement of the $45 billion Hunter-class anti-submarine frigate program has undergone a review by the Australian National Audit Office (ANAO) and warned of further delays and cost blow-outs.
The collective making calls for a AUKUS investigation have penned a letter to the government. Signatories include Former Labor WA Premier the Hon. Carmen Lawrence AO, former Labor Minister the Hon. Peter Garrett AM, Former Shadow Minister Doug Cameron and Former Labor Minister the Hon. Melissa Parke.
Former Chief of the Air Force Air Marshall Ray Funnell AC, and Former Dep. Commander of the UN Peacekeeping Operation in East Timor Major General Michael Smith AO also supported the calls.
The concerns raised include, the cost to the budget, the proposed approximate four-decade timeframe for delivery and shortage of local workforce and skills.
“For a policy of this magnitude and strategic significance, the AUKUS deal for nuclear-powered submarines has been politically rushed. It requires appropriate scrutiny in the national interest,” said Allan Behm, Director of the Australia Institute’s International & Security Affairs Program.
“At $268-368b this is one of the most expensive spending commitments ever made in Defence, with huge implications for our sovereignty that rightly require appropriate Parliamentary oversight.”
Meanwhile, an ANAO report, tabled in Parliament in May, has slammed the procurement processes for the Hunter-class program to provide nine frigates optimised for anti-submarine warfare to replace the Anzac class frigates.
The deal to commission the fleet was signed in December 2018 under then Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull.
The ANAO suggested “further training and oversight may be required of Defence officials involved in high-level planning and advising on major capital acquisition projects, at all levels”, Australian Defence Magazine reports.
Contract expenditure to date had not been effective in delivering on project milestones for Sea 5000 Phase 1, and “lack of design maturity” had resulted in a fresh 18-month delay to the project, says the ANAO.
The first of the nine Hunter-class vessels intended to replace the RAN’s Anzac-class frigates are expected to be delivered in mid-2032 rather than early 2031.


